Wednesday, August 7, 2013

State of the Collection Part 1

Borrowing a page from Dicetower News videos where Tom Vasel talks about a gaming shelf and why he's keeping each game on that shelf, I wanted to do a series of posts where I discuss why I'm keeping the games I am, what I like about those games, and even some of the games I might consider trading/selling.  

To make things easy, ratings will be out of 6.
1 - Ready to trade/sell
2 - Considering trading/selling, willing to give another chance
3 - Might trade/sell, not my favorite, but has a time and place to play. Perhaps is around more for others than myself.
4 - I like the game but there's something that stops me from liking it more.  Maybe I don't get to play it often enough, maybe there's a minor irritation with some rules or the way something works.  
5 - I enjoy the game. It works well in most situations. I would be hard pressed to let it go, but it could happen in the distant future.
6 - Love the game, keeping it, never letting it go.

First, let's look at what's currently in my to go bag.  This is my go to set of games that I take with me to just about any gaming event.  Some games will change, but most are staples of the bag.  

  • Article 27 - 5. A big hit with my Friday night group.  One of the only pure negotiation games I own.  Players have so much freedom with this game, it's fun to watch everyone's behavior.
  • Coloretto - 3.  More often than not, I forget I have it around.  I like the set collection aspect, and the choice of when to take cards.  It's a deep card game and one I should play more often.
  • Eight-Minute Empire - 5.  It's just too easy to pull this out at the start of game night while we wait for other people to show up.  Yes, it always takes longer than 8 minutes, but it's a fast game and very enjoyable for the short time.
  • For Sale - 5.  A quick auction filler game.  There isn't a ton of strategy, which is good for new players, but there's enough that I still enjoy it 20+ games in.
  • Hanabi - 4.  Since I've only had this game for a week and a half, it's hard to rate it perfectly, but I'm enjoying it so far.  In ways, it's more of a challenge than a game, yet that makes it unique in my collection.  Trying to maximize your clues and deduce things about your hand while trying to stay on the course for a perfect game is a huge challenge.
  • Incan Gold - 6.  A great push your luck game that stretches up to 8 players, making it very versatile.
  • King of Tokyo (w/ Power Up exp) - 6.  KoT is one of those games that I can play in any gaming situation.  It's a fun and relatively fast dice chucking game with an engaging theme.
  • No Thanks - 5.  A quick filler card game.  There's luck with what cards come out, and when players decide to take cards.  There's also enough strategy to keep things interesting.
  • Resistance Avalon - 6.  This game is only a week and a half old for me, but in the 4 games I've played of it, I love it.  It's an absolutely fascinating experience of trying to figure out who's who based on every little thing that they do.  The game certainly makes you think, but I really enjoy it.
  • Smash Up (w/ Awesome Level 9000 exp) 3.  This card game still has me on the fence.  I love the ideas in the game, but it always seems to take too long to play.  Maybe we're all just thinking too long, but I still think things could be done to speed it up.
  • Tiki Topple - 4.  This isn't a perfect game, some would even say this isn't even a good game, but something about it just makes me smile.  Maybe it's saying the names of the Tiki's like Wikiwiki or Huhu.  This game brings out a silly side of me, and I enjoy playing it near the end of the night.
  • TransAmerica - 4.  This has been a hit with the Friday night group because of the subtle strategy.  The two big choices are when to connect to other players and when to use your colored tracks to block.  I try to play with the Vexation expansion as often as I can, but I do still enjoy the game without it.
  • Tsuro - 5.  It's seeing less play lately as compared to last year, but that's ok.  It still gets played from time to time.  It's a quick tile game, that is really easy to teach anyone.
So that's what's in my to go bag.  As you'd figure, it's a lot of the best games for me right now, and a lot of what I've been playing lately.  I'm going to try to get a post out a day, I'll probably look at 10 games per day, so it should take me a little more than a week to get them all out.  

Munchkin Review or I Told You Not to Pick Up a Duck in a Dungeon


Munchkin
  • Designed by Steve Jackson
  • Published by Steve Jackson Games
  • For 3-6 players (I prefer 3 or 4, maybe 5, but never 6.)
  • Playtime on the box is 90 minutes, but it can be shorter (rare) or more like 120-150 minutes.
Catch
Go into a dungeon with your friends, kill everything you meet, backstab so called friends, take their stuff, grab the loot and get out.

Mechanics
On your turn, you draw and reveal the top door card.  There are a lot of different cards but they go into 4 main groups. 1) Monsters, 2) Curses, 3)Races/Classes, 4) Other things to use later.  If you encounter a monster, you are immediately in combat.  Combat is relatively simple, you add your level plus any item bonuses and see if that total is higher than the monster's level.  If it is, you win and take treasure.  If it isn't, then you either have to try to get someone to help you by offering a split of the treasure, or try to run away.  Curses cause bad things to happen to you. Most curses involve loosing a piece of equipment or a level.  Play continues until one person defeats a monster causing them to go to level 10.  At that point they win and everyone rejoices that the game is finally over. (sorry, spoilers)

Interaction
The interaction in Munchkin is certainly abundant.  Players are often angling to help in order to get a split of the loot, but are also levying "threats" along the lines of "take me or I'll add 5 to that monster."  The game depends on the interaction of players, and can fall completely flat if players aren't willing to work against each other to some degree.

Theme
The theme here is fairly strong.  The cards all evoke a sense of going through a dungeon.  They play on many of the D&D and GURPS character tropes in a fun way.  It isn't immersive, but it exists and allows players to get as much theme out of it as they want.  My problem with the game is that when I'm a Cleric, I don't really do anything in the game differently than when I'm a Warrior.  Also Dwarves don't feel that different from Elves or Halflings.  I know all these things have different abilities, but they don't really change how the game actually plays out.

Components
My one complaint with the game is that it doesn't have a built in way to track levels.  Outside of that, the cards are all good quality, the artwork is well done, especially in a color set (which I don't own.)

Learning Curve
I can explain Munchkin in around 5 minutes, but it takes several rounds for players to really understand what's going on.

Replayability
I've played Munchkin 14 times over the last several years.  You will rarely get through the entire deck in a single play, so there is variety to be had.  The distribution of cards, especially in the treasure deck, keeps things interesting in different games.  Changing the people you play with really helps keep the game fresh.  I played with the same group too many times and it ceased to be fun.

Why I like Munchkin
The game is random and offers a lot of player interaction.  It's not a terrible way to spend time with some roleplayers who might enjoy a card game, which could lead to other games.

Why I don't like Munchkin
The game has balance issues, pick on the leader issues, and worst of all, the potential to never end.  Players start off far too weak to be able to combat higher level monsters, and you can easily be out of the game within the first 20 minutes, yet have to sit there for another hour or more.

Overall
I still own Munchkin, but that is more due to not having much trade value or sell value, as opposed to actually liking the game.  I played Munchkin back in March with 4 players, all of whom were new, and we actually had a decent time of it.  I still feel like I have no control, and no real way to play better or worse.  I'll keep it on my shelf because it's fairly small, and there are good times in the box.

Variants/Houserules
I've made some changes to the deck distribution, something I rarely do, but I've felt it was necessary.  I took out a few of the nastier monsters in the level 14-18 range.  I also play with a rule where everyone starts at level 5 and we play to 10 (for a short game) or 15 (for a normal length game).  This makes it easier to defeat monsters in the beginning, which really helps the game move along, and play in closer to 60 minutes.

Would it be a good game for Tabletop?
Yes, in fact they already made an episode of it.


Want to buy the game? Here's a link to Amazon, and you'll help support BoBG.  Here are a bunch of different themes on Munchkin, so you can pick whatever you think you'd like the best.



Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Dominion: Guilds Review


Reviewing expansions takes a bit of a different format for me.  I assume that you have some familiarity with the base game, either having played it, or at least heard about it.  With that in mind, let's take a look at Dominion Guilds

Each Dominion set has a general theme/mechanic.  Seaside had durations, Prosperity had a lot of treasure, Dark Ages had trashing, and Guilds introduces Coin tokens, as well as overpaying.  Guilds is the expansion that offers the most options when buying cards, and makes deck construction even more challenging.  Coin tokens are gained through several different cards.  They stay in front of you, and you can use any number on a turn to increase your buying power.  I really like coin tokens since they almost always eliminate that $7 hand.


If you don't want to read all my thoughts on cards, go ahead and skip down to the end now.

  • Advisor (Cost 4)  +1 action, reveal the top 3 cards of your deck. The player to your left picks one for you to discard, add the other 2 to your hand.  I like the card, maybe a bit more than I should.  It's a better and worse version of Envoy.  The action really helps to build a stable engine.  You're never going to get the best card, but sometimes your opponent doesn't know what the best card for you to lose is.  Advisor isn't amazing, but it's solid.
  • Baker (5) +1 card, +1 action, +1 coin token.  At the start of the game, each player gets a coin token.  Baker shifts the entire game at the start.  Now you can have a 4/4, a 5/3, or a 6/2 opening depending on what you draw and how you want to spend the token, if you even want to spend it to start.  The card itself is interesting, on a similar level to Market(base).  It's important to remember that Bakers don't give you money, just the coin token.  They're flexible, but most of the time you'll spend the coin tokens that turn.  
  • Butcher (5) Take 2 coin tokens.  You may trash a card.  Then gain a card equal to the value of the trashed card plus any coin tokens you wish to spend.  At worst, Butcher is a Remodel(base), but it's so much more flexible than that.  My favorite Butcher moment is Butchering a Doctor, adding 5 coin tokens, and making a Province.
  • Candlestick Maker (2) +1 action, +1 buy, gain a coin token.  At worst, Candlestick Maker is a copper that also gives you a bonus buy.  At best, it's a coin on a future turn that may just be enough to win the game.  I think CM is one of the best 2 cost cards in the game now, and it fits in to most decks.
  • Doctor (3+) Name a card. Reveal the top 3 cards of your deck. Trash the matches. Put the rest back on top in any order.  When you buy this, you may overpay. For each $1 you overpaid, look at the top card of your deck; trash it, discard it, or put it back.  I rarely overpay by more than 1 for the Doctor, making it a 4 cost, with a nice set up ability.  It's also a perfectly good card at $3.  The Doctor is great for getting rid of curses, estates, copper, and even those pesky Rats from Dark Ages.  It's controlled deck thinning, and it gives you the advantage of clearing up your next hand, or at least part of it.
  • Herald (4+) +1 Card, +1 Action. Reveal the top card of your deck. If it is an action, play it.  When you buy it, for each $1 you overpay, you may put a card from your discard pile on top of your deck.  First off, the card text alone is worth a buy at 4, even 5.  The overpay is the best in the set in my opinion.  Overpaying on Herald sets up your next hand, which is a great thing.  Heralds themselves build an action engine better than any other card.
  • Journeyman (5) Name a card. Reveal cards from your deck until you reveal 3 cards that aren't the named card. Put those cards in your hand, discard the rest.  Essentially, this is a Smithy(base) where you control 1 card you don't get.
  • Masterpiece (3+) Worth $1.  When you buy this, you gain a silver for each $1 you overpay.  Masterpiece is a tricky balance.  It's never worth buying at $3 since it's just a copper. At $4 or $5 it's great for added silver, but you have to weigh the benefit of silver over another 4 or 5.
  • Merchant Guild (5) +1 Buy, +$1.  When you buy a card, gain a coin token.  Merchant Guild is a nice bonus card, but it's tricky to build a deck around it.  I would love to add Merchant Guild to a Goons (Prosperity) and Gardens (base) game.
  • Plaza (4) +1 Card, +2 Actions. You may discard a treasure card from your hand. If you do, gain a coin token.  Plaza is a Village with potential for more.  If you have $7 in your hand, you go down to $6, and get a coin later.  To me, there's now downside to Plaza other than that it's not the best $4 in the world.  
    • Soothsayer (5) Gain a Gold.  Each other player gains a curse.  Each player who gains a curse, draws a card.  Gaining a gold is a great card.  Add in giving other players a curse and Soothsayer is a good card. 
    • Stonemason (2+) Trash a card from your hand. Gain 2 cards each costing less than the trashed card.  When you buy a Stonemason, you may overpay.  Then you gain 2 action cards each costing the amount you overpaid.  I'm not the biggest fan of Stonemason, but I acknowledge the usefulness of the card.  The card is all about timing, and maybe some luck.  The action part of the card is good on its own.  Add in the overpay when buying, and you have a solid 2 cost.
    • Taxman (4) Trash a treasure card.  Each player with 5+ cards in hand must discard a copy of that treasure card from their hand.  Gain a treasure card costing up to $3 more than the card you trashed and put it on top of your deck..  Essentially, this is an attacking version of Mine(base) with delayed gratification.  Playing against Taxman can be trying since it usually feels like the other player picks the one card you have to keep.  I like Taxman better than Mine.

    Some of my favorite cards in this set, in no particular order, are Butcher, Candlestick Maker and Herald.  I enjoy all of the cards in different ways.  Masterpiece is probably my least favorite card in Guilds.

    Here's the big question, where does Guilds rate overall?  Well, I really do like it.  The set is not friendly to new players, since it offers more choices with what to buy and how to spend those coin tokens.  The idea of overpaying is great to have, but also a challenge to figure out.

    If I was telling you what expansion(s) to get for Dominion, I wouldn't say Guilds first.  I think I'd buy Guilds before I bought Cornucopia, Hinterlands and Alchemy.  

    Want to buy Dominion: Guilds and support BoBG?



    Thursday, August 1, 2013

    July 2013 Recap

    Another 31 days and a new month.


    July saw a lot of gaming

    I played 64 games in 31 days, gaining a whole lot.  That brings the YTD total to 248/365.  Ideally I would be at 212, so 36 ahead and cushion for the August/September slowdown that always seems to happen.  I played 6 games for the first time this year, which brings me up to 72/100.



    Just a quick list of what I actually played in June

    8 Times
    • King of Tokyo

    7 Times
    • Dominion
    6 Times
    • Incan Gold
    5 Times
    • Article 27
    4 Times
    • TransAmerica
    • Tsuro
    3 Times
    • Eight-Minute Empire
    • Hanabi
    • Resistance: Avalon
    2 Times
    • Flash Point
    • For Sale
    • Order Up
    • Qwixx
    • Tiki Topple
    1 Time
    • 23
    • Colossal Arena
    • Cosmic Encounter
    • Eclipse
    • Elfenland
    • Las Vegas
    • Race for the Galaxy
    • Shadows Over Camelot (Yay for me being the traitor King and winning)
    • Smash Up
    • Survive
    • Thurn and Taxis

    I acquired 2 new games - Hanabi and Resistance: Avalon, and 1 new expansion - Dominion: Guilds  this month.
    Speaking of Dominion, the reason I played it 7 times was due to a tournament where I played 6 games. I managed to come in 2nd, losing in the finals by 1 point.  I know there are things I could have done differently, but the guy who won deserved it.  

    Looking ahead to August, who knows what's going to happen with my game plays.  Historically they have a drop-off with the new school year, but maybe this year will be different. (Yes that's what everyone likes to say.)

    In July I reviewed  the Smash Up expansion.  I also got back on the whole Top 7 list, which I hope to be doing more of.  Yes, I'm shamelessly piggybacking on Dice Tower Top 10 lists, but I think it's worth throwing my thoughts out there.  I'm working on a couple ideas for reviews, trying to bring a little different flavor to cover a couple of games.  I also finished a major revision to SR, so we'll see how that goes.  More on that soon.

    Until next time, thanks for reading.

    Wednesday, July 31, 2013

    Emergence

    Warning, this is a heavy and thoughtful post.  Do not read before having your morning coffee.

    Emergence is the changing group dynamics and player interaction that happens during and in between games.  This isn't a complete definition, nor is it even 100% accurate, but it's what I mean when I use the term.  Episode 45 of Ludology spent far more time talking about this, and doing a better job of probing the depths of it than I could ever do.  Ever since I listened to the podcast, I've been noticing emergence all over the place.

    I think an example of this helps more than anything.  The other night, I was playing Resistance Avalon with people who had never played before, or who had only played once.  In our first game, there was very little table talk until I started pushing it.  See, the first time I played Resistance, I didn't know enough about the game or the other people to feel comfortable with the direct accusations of "you're a spy" and so on, but this time we were all more comfortable with each other.  In our second game, the table talk flew around for most people, and that was great.  In the third game, even our quietest player was jumping in on the accusations and everyone was really trying to figure everything out.

    Now, here's where you say something like "Well that's because Resistance is supposed to work that way." or "Players naturally do that when they are more comfortable with a game."  Those are both good points, but that's part of emergent behavior.

    Players will start to think of things on a higher level the more they play a game.  Let me give you another example of a game.  In Hanabi, players are working together to play cards in order without messing up.  The catch is that you can see everyone's hand of cards except your own.  On your turn you can only tell someone about a number in their hand, or a color in their hand.  But what do you do if someone has say a 1,2,3 in red? Well, maybe you touch the cards in the proper order as you say "this, this and this are red." Some might say that that's cheating, but I call it emergent behavior.  Both players have to understand the code.  There are other aspects to that game that demonstrate emergent behavior, but let's leave that for the review.

    In the aforementioned Ludology podcast, they use Go as a leading example of emergence.  Since I don't know much about the game, I'll use Chess as a counter example.  Chess has seen the rise and fall of strategies over the years.  There is no perfect strategy, but there are strategies that can be hard to beat.  The more you play against one opponent, the more you have to change what you do, else they would learn how to beat you every time.

    Perhaps the simplest example is Rock Paper Scissors.  Each part has something that it beats, and something it loses to.  It leads to looking for emergence as you try to detect patterns in your opponent.  What I'm getting at here is that emergence is all around us.  It's one of the aspects that makes gaming great.  Good games will lead to emergence.  Strategies will rise and fall.  Players will have to try something, fail, react, change, fail, alter, fail, try again, and perhaps fail.  It can be a frustrating process, but cracking that code and seeing something for the first time can be one of the most satisfying experiences in life.

    As it relates to game design, emergence is crucial.  Sure, not every game has to have emergent behavior, but most tend to have some amount of it.  Rules establish a framework for what we can and cannot do, but they often leave room for strategy and choices that even the designer didn't envision.
    Take Tic-Tac-Toe for instance.  The rules, start with a 3x3 grid, make a mark in a grid that no one else has marked in, connect 3 in a row to win.  There's strategy there, and choices.  Yes, it's been solved, but there is still the opportunity for emergence when someone learns the game.

    The unexpected is often what makes life worth living.  Trying to find something new, something that is in the realm of the constraints that have been established for us, but is something that no one has thought of before.

    Monday, July 29, 2013

    Top 7 Games that are Better with Expansion(s)

    First of all, note that this is not a list of the top 7 expansions.  This is a list of games that are good alone, but great with an expansion or expansions, and a list of games that might be ok by themselves but become better with expansions.  Either way, the expansion(s) to a game make it better than it is by itself.

    #7  Settlers of Catan
    I enjoy basic Settlers.  I enjoy Settlers with Seafarers and/or Cities and Knights more.  The other expansions have their merits, but they're not as good in my own opinion.  Basic Settlers is a fine game, but it needs a little extra something to make each resource feel important.  Seafarers gives sheep an added importance while C&K changes up the game in many ways.  These do add time, but I think that either is worth including to make the game better.

    #6  Formula D
    Expansions to Formula D are new tracks to race on, but the thrill of racing games is learning how to race on new tracks.  If you race on the same layout every time, eventually you know exactly how to best get around, provided your dice cooperate.  Being able to race on 8 different tracks gives me a lot options right now, though more tracks would be nice to have.

    #5  Rattus
    Specifically the Pied Piper expansion.  The base game comes with 6 powers, but you use all 6 in every game.  That leads to some strategies becoming dominant, and samey gameplay.  Pied Piper adds 12 more powers, yet you still only play with 6.  That really changes up the game and leads to a lot of variety between games.

    #4  Carcassonne
    Carcassonne has many expansions, very few of which are necessary, but several of which enhance the game in some way.  Basic Carcassonne is a fine game, but it really needs the first expansion (Inns and Cathedrals) to make it a more strategic experience.  This is a game where you can't play with everything every time you play it, the game would take too long.  Adding in some expansions makes Carc a more enjoyable game, just don't go overboard.

    #3  Pandemic
    On the Brink changed Pandemic in so many ways that one could argue that it is an essential expansion. OtB more than doubled the available roles that players can use to try to win the game.  This alone would be an expansion worth owning, but when you add in several new ways to play the game, OtB greatly enhances Pandemic.  I liked the basic game of Pandemic, but after 20 plays, I needed something more.  OtB made it harder in ways and easier in others, which when combined made for a much more enjoyable gaming experience.

    #2  Dominion
    Though I own every expansion to Dominion, I won't argue that they are all necessary.  However, adding in at least 1 expansion makes Dominion a better game.  Each set has a general theme, so the cards in any set tend to combo well with each other.  Once you start mixing things, the combos get more interesting, and setting up a deck becomes a bigger challenge.  The nice thing is that the choices in any given game don't expand a lot, but the variety of games goes up exponentially.  So for not a lot of extra difficulty, and a lot of added replay value, Dominion is the #2 game that gets better with expansions.

    #1  X-Wing
    This game would be nothing without expansion ships and upgrades.  They are what makes this game compelling and challenging.  In ways this is cheating since it's a miniatures game.  You have to have multiple units for it to be playable, but the game does have a core set that works on its own.  There is fun in that single box with 2 Tie Fighters and 1 X-Wing, but adding in more ships truly makes the game special.

    For links to many of these games and their expansions, click on the BoBG store link in the header.

    Tuesday, July 23, 2013

    Smash Up: Awesome Level 9000 Expansion Review


    Since I'm reviewing an expansion, my normal format kinda goes to the wayside.  With any expansion, the main question one has to ask is something along the lines of "does this offer enough extra things to warrant the price?"  Now those extra things come in many shapes and sizes.

    Awesome Level 9000, an expansion for Smash Up, offers 2 things - 4 new decks, and victory point tokens.  First off, let me say thank-you for the victory point tokens.  These were needed from the get go, and I'm glad the publisher saw the need for them and included them in this expansion.  Those alone do not justify buying the expansion, but they don't hurt the cause.  Let's talk about the 4 new decks - Plants, Ghosts, Steampunk, and Bear Cavalry.  Yes, you can now have Plants versus Zombies, or even Plant-Zombie combo.  Each of these 4 decks do bring something new to the table.  Ghosts encourage small hands of cards and cycling to power up your minions.  Steampunk use action cards to move around and do a lot of crazy things.  Plants work to bring more minions out and then to take root where they are.  Bear Cavalry are strong, they destroy minions with as much glee as Ninjas, and they have some actions which make them really hard to mess with.

    These 4 new decks are a great addition to the game.  It doesn't feel like there's a power creep, which is a good thing.  Each deck certainly has their abilities, but it's up to each player to maximize their combinations.  Ghosts are an expert level deck, while the rest feel medium to me.  Maybe the Bear Cavalry is an easy deck to play, it all just really depends on your style.

    So, the verdict on Awesome Level 9000 is that is a worthwhile expansion for Smash Up.  Having 4 more decks offers a lot of new combinations to explore, and shakes up some of the strategies.  Plus, you'll no longer see every faction in a 4 player game.   If you like Smash Up and you're looking for something more, buy Awesome Level 9000.

    Missed my review of the base game? You can read it here.

    Want to buy the expansion and support BoBG?