Yes, that's right, it's Secret Santa time. Now, I've been involved with two Secret Santas, Boardgamegeek (3 years) and Dice Tower (2 years). I've had a blast with both, especially last year. See, last year, I was at home, so I had some more time to personalize things and get creative. I went so far as to have an SS e-mail account to go back and forth with my target. The thing I enjoyed most of all, was being able to send some almonds. My Dicetower target was a lot of fun, he really got into the guessing game and going back and forth with things. My BGG target wasn't in the same holiday mood, but to each their own.
Giving games to others is really the part of the process that excites me the most. Sure, I love getting new games, especially when I don't know what they are, but being able to provide a gaming gift to a fellow gamer is truly a joy. To that end, I've also signed up for the BGG Christmas Card Exchange, which is another fun way to spread the holiday cheer.
On the receiving end, I've had some mixed experiences, and no, this has nothing to do with the games I received.
The first year(2009) I got Dominion: Seaside and Acquire. Both are games/expansion I enjoy and still play today, but Santa didn't really do anything above and beyond. There was no taunting, no communication beyond. Now, I know some Santas like to be secretive, and that's all well and good, I just appreciate something a little more fun.
The next year (2010) was really a mix. I was in 2, DT and BGG. I got an e-mail from my DT Santa in mid-November saying that packages were on the way. I got them at Thanksgiving, along with a very nice Christmas card. I was able to correspond with my Santa a couple of times, and had a great time doing that. He went above and beyond in customizing Roll Through the Ages for me, and with additions of Incan Gold and No Thanks, he's definitely been the Santa who's provided the highest ranked games for me. That was the awesome part one. BGG was a lesson in patience. My first Santa had something come up and he wasn't able to follow through, same with my 2nd Santa. Well, the 3rd one made up for everything, and even though I was the last person to get games, I know that I was blessed by it, and that my Santa was blessed for being so very generous.
2011 was better. BGG still arrived late (Valentines day this time) but DT was early, so it balanced out, plus extended Christmas.
I've learned many lessons is patience and delayed gratification from Secret Santa. It would be easy to focus on the negative aspects, but when I've read the words of joy that come from my targets, it makes everything worth it. If I think about the smiles I've gotten from reading my targets posts, and the smiles I've gotten from getting my own games, they come out pretty even. But when I factor in the smiles my Santas have gotten from my posts, I know without a doubt that it is better to give than to receive.
With that, consider joining a secret santa. You can find the info for BGG at this link. For info on the Dicetower Secret Santa, you'll need to listen to episode 276.
You don't have much time, I think both are closing in early November, so sign-up now and make a fellow geek happy in the holiday season.
Also, a promise from me, games are staying wrapped until Christmas Eve this year.
This blog aims to provide quality reviews on various board games, as well as share experiences and thoughts on games and gaming in general. Come on in, make yourself at home, comment to your heart's content.
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Wednesday, October 24, 2012
Collection Building: Next Level Games
Many gamers ponder where to go after the into/gateway games. They like the ideas put forth in those types of games, but they want something a little deeper, a little longer, maybe a little bit more complicated. Many factors come in to play here, but the key question is what have they played. Here are some of the games I've had success with when it comes to furthering someone's interest/love in games.
Acquire
Acquire is a classic from noted designer Sid Sackson. Players place tiles on the board to increase the size of hotels. They then buy stock in hotel chains on the board. The goal is to merge hotels, have your hotel taken over so you get paid out on stock, and then to invest in large hotels for the end of the game. It's not the most intuitive game at first, but it is a familiar concept for many adults due to the stock nature of the game. It takes about 90 minutes to play, and it makes you think, but I enjoy it from time to time.
Cosmic Encounter
Cosmic is the second designer game that I ever played, so it has a soft spot in my heart. Getting into the game can take time due to a variety of card effects, but this is less for all new players. Cosmic focuses on hand management and negotiation. It is a confrontational game, but rarely is it a "beat-up on one person" game. Cosmic has a great deal of variety, with 50 unique player powers in the base game, and 20 in each expansion. Cosmic is a great game, but it is not for everyone. There are moments of backstabbing and cunning plans, there are times where you pull a rabbit out of your hat that annoys everyone else. There are ways to be nice, ways to be mean, and ways to be everything in-between. If you take Cosmic too seriously, you won't have fun with it. But if you're willing to laugh things off and not let a loss ruin your day, it's hard to say no.
Mystery Express
Fan of Clue? Here's a fun deduction game that adds a lot of variety and options to that experience. Mystery Express simulates a murder on the Orient Express, except for the ending. Players spend time to investigate 4 categories - suspect, location, motive and modus operendi. Unlike Clue, there are two copies of each card, so players have to figure out which card only has one copy in circulation. There are various means to see cards, as well as trade cards, which makes the whole investigation more complicated. The game takes around an hour, and it's great for people who really like Clue or deductive games.
Power Grid
Power Grid is probably the heaviest game for next level, and because of that, it probably appeals to the smallest group, but in the right group, it's a great game. Power Grid is all about getting power plants to fuel cities, buying the resources to run the power plants, and expanding into cities. You have to balance all three aspects so you're not wasting power, or buying resources at a high price, and certainly so you don't get blocked out of cities. If this all sounds like a big spreadsheet, it kinda is. The thing is, that other players influence things, and change what you want to do throughout the game. I see it as a big economic puzzle, with some key choices on when to do certain things. It is long, roughly 2 hours, but most games are close until the very end.
Rattus
What's more fun than the Black Death? Well, many things, and that's true of games. There are games that are funnier than Rattus, but Rattus is still a fun game. It loosely falls under the "Area Control" umbrella, meaning that you're trying to have cubes on the board and survive. Through the game, you will use different roles to do different things. Each role lets you do something special, like add extra cubes, make a cube safe forever, etc. but each power you have makes you more likely to lose cubes when the plague hits. For more info on Rattus, read my review.
Price Wars
As you can see, most of these games are fairly pricy. The good thing is, they're fairly hefty games, and you're getting a lot out of them. It all really depends on what you're looking for in a gaming experience. I'd say that Power Grid is probably the best bang for your buck, Mystery Express will probably appeal to the most people, and Cosmic Encounter offers the most variety.
If I have to pick one and only one, I'm taking Cosmic for the replayability.
Acquire
Acquire is a classic from noted designer Sid Sackson. Players place tiles on the board to increase the size of hotels. They then buy stock in hotel chains on the board. The goal is to merge hotels, have your hotel taken over so you get paid out on stock, and then to invest in large hotels for the end of the game. It's not the most intuitive game at first, but it is a familiar concept for many adults due to the stock nature of the game. It takes about 90 minutes to play, and it makes you think, but I enjoy it from time to time.
Cosmic Encounter
Cosmic is the second designer game that I ever played, so it has a soft spot in my heart. Getting into the game can take time due to a variety of card effects, but this is less for all new players. Cosmic focuses on hand management and negotiation. It is a confrontational game, but rarely is it a "beat-up on one person" game. Cosmic has a great deal of variety, with 50 unique player powers in the base game, and 20 in each expansion. Cosmic is a great game, but it is not for everyone. There are moments of backstabbing and cunning plans, there are times where you pull a rabbit out of your hat that annoys everyone else. There are ways to be nice, ways to be mean, and ways to be everything in-between. If you take Cosmic too seriously, you won't have fun with it. But if you're willing to laugh things off and not let a loss ruin your day, it's hard to say no.
Mystery Express
Fan of Clue? Here's a fun deduction game that adds a lot of variety and options to that experience. Mystery Express simulates a murder on the Orient Express, except for the ending. Players spend time to investigate 4 categories - suspect, location, motive and modus operendi. Unlike Clue, there are two copies of each card, so players have to figure out which card only has one copy in circulation. There are various means to see cards, as well as trade cards, which makes the whole investigation more complicated. The game takes around an hour, and it's great for people who really like Clue or deductive games.
Power Grid
Power Grid is probably the heaviest game for next level, and because of that, it probably appeals to the smallest group, but in the right group, it's a great game. Power Grid is all about getting power plants to fuel cities, buying the resources to run the power plants, and expanding into cities. You have to balance all three aspects so you're not wasting power, or buying resources at a high price, and certainly so you don't get blocked out of cities. If this all sounds like a big spreadsheet, it kinda is. The thing is, that other players influence things, and change what you want to do throughout the game. I see it as a big economic puzzle, with some key choices on when to do certain things. It is long, roughly 2 hours, but most games are close until the very end.
Rattus
What's more fun than the Black Death? Well, many things, and that's true of games. There are games that are funnier than Rattus, but Rattus is still a fun game. It loosely falls under the "Area Control" umbrella, meaning that you're trying to have cubes on the board and survive. Through the game, you will use different roles to do different things. Each role lets you do something special, like add extra cubes, make a cube safe forever, etc. but each power you have makes you more likely to lose cubes when the plague hits. For more info on Rattus, read my review.
Price Wars
As you can see, most of these games are fairly pricy. The good thing is, they're fairly hefty games, and you're getting a lot out of them. It all really depends on what you're looking for in a gaming experience. I'd say that Power Grid is probably the best bang for your buck, Mystery Express will probably appeal to the most people, and Cosmic Encounter offers the most variety.
If I have to pick one and only one, I'm taking Cosmic for the replayability.
Monday, October 22, 2012
Flip Men - A For Sale Review

For Sale
- Designed by Stefan Dorra
- Published by Uberplay in 1997, more recently by Gryphon Games which is the version I have.
- For 3-6 players, I recommend 4+. 3 works, but lacks some of the dynamics in bidding.
- Plays in 15-20 minutes.
Overview
For Sale is the 4th game in the Gryphon Bookshelf line, and a relatively fast filler game. The point of the game is to bid on properties, and then use those properties to cash in on checks later in the game. It's a game of buy low, sell high, and a neat game for a 15-20 minute play time.
Components
![]() |
| Inside the box - baggie not included |
For Sale isn't going to wow anyone with its components. There are 60 cards and a slew of money tokens in the game. That's it. Now, the artwork on the cards is rather amusing. The "1" value property is a cardboard box, or as my group likes to call it, "The Philosophy/English major's home." The "30" is a space station. Other cards include a lighthouse, a doghouse, a teepee, a tree house, and an outhouse.
Mechanics
For Sale is played through 2 distinct phases. In the first phase, players bid on properties. One property per player is flipped up, and the start player makes a bid. The next player can outbid them or pass. When someone passes, they pay half their bid and then take the lowest valued property. When it's down to the last person, they pay their full bid and get the highest property. After all the properties have been auctioned off, players then sell properties for cash. Once again, one check is turned up for each player in the game, but this time, players secretly select a property from their hand. Players then take the check corresponding to their place in the property numbers, high number gets the high check and so on. After all the checks are gone, the player with the most money wins.
| Money tokens used for bidding |
Interaction
Anytime bidding occurs in a game, there is player interaction. It's the old game of figuring out your top price, someone else's top price, and balancing that against what something is worth. There is the question of when to outbid someone, and when to pass, but it isn't the most interactive of choices. There's really nothing you can do to another player, besides outbid them, that messes with their plan.
Theme
![]() |
| Some of the housing options |
Buying and selling houses isn't exactly the most engaging theme in the world, but it works really well for this game. Sure, you're really just focused on the numbers, but the variety of houses is great. That part really appeals to non-gamers. They understand buying and selling houses. Kids also get a kick out of it, though they may make odd choices just so they get certain properties rather than the numbers. I do like the theme, I think it fits the game well.
Learning Curve
![]() |
| Checks |
Short, very short. Teach the game in 2 phases. Seriously. Just explain the bidding phase, and when that's done, explain the checks. I can teach For Sale in under 2 minutes, probably under 1 if I had to. It's really accessible, the game makes sense right away. There is some strategy in the check phase, but that's not as important in a short game.
Why I like For Sale
This is one of those few games that I can truly play with anyone. It's not overly complex, so it doesn't turn people off. The artwork is great, the gameplay is solid. The player range is also great, not many fillers go up to 6 players.
Why I don't like For Sale
![]() |
| Properties matched with checks |
I've really had a hard time coming up with something I don't like about For Sale. There is luck in the game, sometimes to frustrating levels, but some of that is self inflicted. You can sell the "1" for $5,000, and the "15" for 0, it just depends on the round and what other players decide to bid. Sometimes the game feels too short. Most of the time, I don't have a good idea about who's winning. Still, I'm nitpicking.
Replayability
Amazing replayability here. Because cards come up in different groups, there's always something new to figure out. Sure, you're always using the same 30 houses and the same 30 checks, but it's the combinations that make it different. I've played 19 times so far, and I'm up to play it basically any time someone else wants to.
Overall
For Sale gets a big two thumbs up from me. I can play it with anyone, I can play it at anytime. It's short, it's simple. Essentially, it's everything I look for in a filler game. I highly recommend For Sale for anyone who's looking for a filler game or a quick family game.
Want to buy For Sale and support and BoBG?
Sunday, October 21, 2012
Getting the Rules Wrong
As someone who plays a fair number of games, and ends up explaining the rules half the time, I'm occasionally faced with the conundrum of what to do when I forget a rule or explain a rule the wrong way. I am human, and as a human, I make mistakes. Games have a lot of rules, and a lot can go wrong. Here's my 5 step program towards righting the ship after a botched rule.
Step 1: Getting a rule wrong is not the end of the world.
If players are having a good time, let it go. As long as the game doesn't take too long to play, this probably won't hurt anything. Plus, you might discover an interesting variant.
Step 2: Don't take advantage.
If you find that you could take advantage of a rule omission/mistake, don't do it. Point it out, and then fix it in the following round of scoring, or the next game.
Step 3: Reach consensus.
Most players are forgiving by nature. Still, they have thoughts on how games should go. Try to find a solution that benefits everyone. Maybe this means starting over, which isn't a bad thing if you find the rule early on. Maybe this means sucking it up, losing the game, but playing the right way next time.
Step 4: Try to laugh it off.
Don't come across as someone who doesn't care that they made a mistake, but try to be self deprecating. It's the old stand-up comedian trick, if a joke bombs, make a joke about how bad the last joke was. If you're having fun, that's the most important part of the game.
Step 5: Learn from the error.
Take this as an opportunity to learn from a mistake and do better the next time. As a game explainer, you're going to get things wrong from time to time. Do your best to improve your teaching skills, keep players engaged in the learning process, and don't worry about the last mistake. The mark of a great teacher isn't by how few errors they make, it's by the way they deal with the errors they make.
Here's my rule of thumb for what to do based on when I find an error:
In the first 10-20 minutes (depending on game length) try to start over.
After that, insert the rule at the start of a round.
In the last 10-20 minutes of a game, just play the way you've been playing the whole game.
This does vary based on the timing of a rule. If it's something that some players were able to do but not others, then it's best to just play the "wrong" way for the entire game.
The crucial thing that I've learned the first time I play any game is that we're going to do something wrong. First games are learning games. Sure, I'm playing to win, but if rules were forgotten/explained wrong, I won't get worked up over that.
Step 1: Getting a rule wrong is not the end of the world.
If players are having a good time, let it go. As long as the game doesn't take too long to play, this probably won't hurt anything. Plus, you might discover an interesting variant.
Step 2: Don't take advantage.
If you find that you could take advantage of a rule omission/mistake, don't do it. Point it out, and then fix it in the following round of scoring, or the next game.
Step 3: Reach consensus.
Most players are forgiving by nature. Still, they have thoughts on how games should go. Try to find a solution that benefits everyone. Maybe this means starting over, which isn't a bad thing if you find the rule early on. Maybe this means sucking it up, losing the game, but playing the right way next time.
Step 4: Try to laugh it off.
Don't come across as someone who doesn't care that they made a mistake, but try to be self deprecating. It's the old stand-up comedian trick, if a joke bombs, make a joke about how bad the last joke was. If you're having fun, that's the most important part of the game.
Step 5: Learn from the error.
Take this as an opportunity to learn from a mistake and do better the next time. As a game explainer, you're going to get things wrong from time to time. Do your best to improve your teaching skills, keep players engaged in the learning process, and don't worry about the last mistake. The mark of a great teacher isn't by how few errors they make, it's by the way they deal with the errors they make.
Here's my rule of thumb for what to do based on when I find an error:
In the first 10-20 minutes (depending on game length) try to start over.
After that, insert the rule at the start of a round.
In the last 10-20 minutes of a game, just play the way you've been playing the whole game.
This does vary based on the timing of a rule. If it's something that some players were able to do but not others, then it's best to just play the "wrong" way for the entire game.
The crucial thing that I've learned the first time I play any game is that we're going to do something wrong. First games are learning games. Sure, I'm playing to win, but if rules were forgotten/explained wrong, I won't get worked up over that.
Friday, October 19, 2012
A Star Runner Update
It's been 2 months since I've talked about Star Runner, and I've mostly let it sit. I think all good games go through a waiting period. For the most part I'm happy with where the game is, but I like having some time to randomly think it over, and try to play the same game without making tweaks. I was able to play a 4 player game last weekend with 2 new players, and one person who had only played once. This game took longer than I'd like, and it got me thinking about having a "starter" ruleset, or having some other options to speed up the early part of the game. I've also realized that the game is hard to explain. Once you start playing, it makes sense, but until you see what's going on, players don't have a strong notion for what they're trying to do. I'm planning on creating a video which shows how to play the game, so this will help the visual learners out there.
I think I've reached the point where the game is solid, but there are tweaks to be made in terms of card distribution, starting resources, and the ever important tech-tree. One thing that a lot of people have noticed is that the game has a definite narrative arc. For those of you who don't know what that means in gaming terms, it's essentially that the end of the game feels different than the start, that through the game, players have made choices that shape what they're doing at the end. This may have a negative effect on new players, but I feel that it makes the game more rewarding after you've played it once.
The best part about getting Star Runner played was that my friend actually asked me to bring it over without any mention of it from me. She also commented that it's a game she wants to play more often to try out new strategies and attempt to do better than the last time. This is music to my ears, and I think it's what every designer should be striving to achieve.
All that being said, if you're interested in reading rules, and maybe even playtesting, let me know and we'll get in touch. Rules can go out basically as soon as you get ahold of me, playtesting kits will take a bit, but I hope to have some ready to go around Thanksgiving.
I think I've reached the point where the game is solid, but there are tweaks to be made in terms of card distribution, starting resources, and the ever important tech-tree. One thing that a lot of people have noticed is that the game has a definite narrative arc. For those of you who don't know what that means in gaming terms, it's essentially that the end of the game feels different than the start, that through the game, players have made choices that shape what they're doing at the end. This may have a negative effect on new players, but I feel that it makes the game more rewarding after you've played it once.
The best part about getting Star Runner played was that my friend actually asked me to bring it over without any mention of it from me. She also commented that it's a game she wants to play more often to try out new strategies and attempt to do better than the last time. This is music to my ears, and I think it's what every designer should be striving to achieve.
All that being said, if you're interested in reading rules, and maybe even playtesting, let me know and we'll get in touch. Rules can go out basically as soon as you get ahold of me, playtesting kits will take a bit, but I hope to have some ready to go around Thanksgiving.
Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Top 7 Gaming Moments
I spend a lot of time talking about games, but not nearly enough talking about moments in games. Games are memorable based on what happens, the crazy things people do, or making that one roll that wins you a game when you had almost no chance making it. This list is a tribute to those moments, the things in games that I will remember for a long time.
#7 2008 - Starfarers of Catan
Who knew that a Saturday night in December could so drastically alter one's life. A friend of my next door neighbor in the dorms came by and asked if he wanted to play a game. He was heading out, but he said "Ask the guy next door, he likes games." So the guy asked me and I was reading for class, but I decided a diversion would be a nice thing. So there I was, playing a game I had never heard of with 4 people I didn't know, but it was a blast. I got into it really quickly, since it did resemble Catan. I admit to having some amazing luck that game, and I ended up winning because of it. But that's not the important thing. That night sparked 3 good friendships, many nights of nights playing boardgames, mostly Cosmic Encounter, and truly finding where I belonged in College.
#6 2009 - Formula D
My dad and I are big Formula 1 fans, so buying Formula D for Father's Day was a perfect gift. We didn't get around to playing until August, but when we did, what a race. All 4 of us got together, and it was a tight race. My dad and I got out to early leads, but my sister kept things close. Dad and I were neck and neck going into Rascasse (2nd to last turn) when I hit the brakes just a little too late. He was able to come out of the corner in a higher gear, and beat me to the line by about 5 places. My sister was hot on my heels, but she broke late as well, which allowed me to get out ahead. Racing around the streets of Monaco was a great way to break in Formula D.
#5 2007 - First time become lord of Catan
Late in the summer of 2007, I got together with my gaming family to play Catan. I've been playing for nearly 9 months at this point, and I'd yet to win a game. Now, I didn't really mind, since I was having a good time playing, but still, I really wanted to win. I jumped out to an early lead by cornering the ORE market. Most players needed to trade with me in order to build cities or knights, so I was a popular guy. All of that was just enough to get me through, and at the end, I heard those words that felt so good, "All hail lord of Catan."
#4 2010 - First game of Munchkin
I'm not a huge fan of Munchkin these days, but back then I was young and naive. I sat down to learn the game. The rules basically made sense, and everyone seemed to have a good natured attitude towards it. Then things got nasty, as they're prone to do in Munchkin. Things were really close, everyone was at level 8 or 9. Then it happened, DIVINE INTERVENTION, and oh look, I was a Level 9 Cleric, which made me a game winner, along with the other 2 Level 9 Clerics. So we had a 3-way win thanks to Divine Intervention. It has to be the least frustrating game of Munchkin that I've ever played.
#3 2011 - Shadows Over Camelot
In my 32nd game of Shadows, I was finally the traitor. Now, not all of these games have used loyalty cards, but still, that's a lot of Shadows to play Loyal. When I first saw the card I got excited, but I knew I couldn't show it. I was playing Sir Percival, which has the power to look at the top black card before deciding on his evil action. This is fairly useless, unless you have Lancelot's Armor. So, I convinced the knights to let me get the armor. I was victorious in my quest, but I knew I still had to play things loyal. I couldn't always play really bad black cards, but I tried to pick the worse of the two, or at least what I thought would hurt more. As it turns out, the game was running very loyal. Loyal knights seemed to be cruising towards victory. Then it happened, a string of bad black cards, Vivien, Mists of Avalon, Dark Forest, all in quick succession. I knew this was my chance, so on my turn I chose the more hurtful of black cards. I kept this up for 3 rounds, by then I was gathering some attention for my poor card play. That's when I did it, I falsely accused a fellow knight, and then played Fate to send myself to Traitorland. From there it was a relatively easy cruise for me, the game lasted another 2 rounds, and then the knights were no more. Muhahaha.
#2 2012 - 7 Wonders
I was at a game night, and we had an hour left to play. There were 5 of us, 3 who had never played 7 Wonders, so I suggested it as something relatively light. I set off to explaining the rules, and everyone seemed to understand what was going on. There were some questions along the way, but that's to be expected. By the 2nd age, everyone was going at a good clip. In the 3rd age, I knew things were going to be close. There was a lot of coins out there, and several key guilds in play. We tallied up the scores at the end, 46-45-44-42-26. I have never seen the top 4 covered by 4 points, it was intense. The 3 new guys were 45-44-26. I ended up winning, but I didn't think I had it until the score was final. 2 of the guys liked it so much, they went and bought the game for themselves. That's the mark of a good time.
#1 2009 - My 2nd game of Battlestar Galactica
I'm playing President Roslin, and a key crisis comes up early on. My turn comes to add cards, and I put them on the table. My friend Aaron says something to the effect of "That's how a cylon plays cards." I pointed out that I couldn't possibly play cards that hurt us, since both of my colors were positive. He wasn't buying it though. Everyone seemed to ignore it after we passed the check. I was in fact a cylon in that game, and we did win when Admiral Tigh revealed himself as a bomber and destroyed Galactica. Aaron knows me pretty well, and he's perceptive, but for him to call it that early still makes me smile.
#7 2008 - Starfarers of Catan
Who knew that a Saturday night in December could so drastically alter one's life. A friend of my next door neighbor in the dorms came by and asked if he wanted to play a game. He was heading out, but he said "Ask the guy next door, he likes games." So the guy asked me and I was reading for class, but I decided a diversion would be a nice thing. So there I was, playing a game I had never heard of with 4 people I didn't know, but it was a blast. I got into it really quickly, since it did resemble Catan. I admit to having some amazing luck that game, and I ended up winning because of it. But that's not the important thing. That night sparked 3 good friendships, many nights of nights playing boardgames, mostly Cosmic Encounter, and truly finding where I belonged in College.
#6 2009 - Formula D
My dad and I are big Formula 1 fans, so buying Formula D for Father's Day was a perfect gift. We didn't get around to playing until August, but when we did, what a race. All 4 of us got together, and it was a tight race. My dad and I got out to early leads, but my sister kept things close. Dad and I were neck and neck going into Rascasse (2nd to last turn) when I hit the brakes just a little too late. He was able to come out of the corner in a higher gear, and beat me to the line by about 5 places. My sister was hot on my heels, but she broke late as well, which allowed me to get out ahead. Racing around the streets of Monaco was a great way to break in Formula D.
#5 2007 - First time become lord of Catan
Late in the summer of 2007, I got together with my gaming family to play Catan. I've been playing for nearly 9 months at this point, and I'd yet to win a game. Now, I didn't really mind, since I was having a good time playing, but still, I really wanted to win. I jumped out to an early lead by cornering the ORE market. Most players needed to trade with me in order to build cities or knights, so I was a popular guy. All of that was just enough to get me through, and at the end, I heard those words that felt so good, "All hail lord of Catan."
#4 2010 - First game of Munchkin
I'm not a huge fan of Munchkin these days, but back then I was young and naive. I sat down to learn the game. The rules basically made sense, and everyone seemed to have a good natured attitude towards it. Then things got nasty, as they're prone to do in Munchkin. Things were really close, everyone was at level 8 or 9. Then it happened, DIVINE INTERVENTION, and oh look, I was a Level 9 Cleric, which made me a game winner, along with the other 2 Level 9 Clerics. So we had a 3-way win thanks to Divine Intervention. It has to be the least frustrating game of Munchkin that I've ever played.
#3 2011 - Shadows Over Camelot
In my 32nd game of Shadows, I was finally the traitor. Now, not all of these games have used loyalty cards, but still, that's a lot of Shadows to play Loyal. When I first saw the card I got excited, but I knew I couldn't show it. I was playing Sir Percival, which has the power to look at the top black card before deciding on his evil action. This is fairly useless, unless you have Lancelot's Armor. So, I convinced the knights to let me get the armor. I was victorious in my quest, but I knew I still had to play things loyal. I couldn't always play really bad black cards, but I tried to pick the worse of the two, or at least what I thought would hurt more. As it turns out, the game was running very loyal. Loyal knights seemed to be cruising towards victory. Then it happened, a string of bad black cards, Vivien, Mists of Avalon, Dark Forest, all in quick succession. I knew this was my chance, so on my turn I chose the more hurtful of black cards. I kept this up for 3 rounds, by then I was gathering some attention for my poor card play. That's when I did it, I falsely accused a fellow knight, and then played Fate to send myself to Traitorland. From there it was a relatively easy cruise for me, the game lasted another 2 rounds, and then the knights were no more. Muhahaha.
#2 2012 - 7 Wonders
I was at a game night, and we had an hour left to play. There were 5 of us, 3 who had never played 7 Wonders, so I suggested it as something relatively light. I set off to explaining the rules, and everyone seemed to understand what was going on. There were some questions along the way, but that's to be expected. By the 2nd age, everyone was going at a good clip. In the 3rd age, I knew things were going to be close. There was a lot of coins out there, and several key guilds in play. We tallied up the scores at the end, 46-45-44-42-26. I have never seen the top 4 covered by 4 points, it was intense. The 3 new guys were 45-44-26. I ended up winning, but I didn't think I had it until the score was final. 2 of the guys liked it so much, they went and bought the game for themselves. That's the mark of a good time.
#1 2009 - My 2nd game of Battlestar Galactica
I'm playing President Roslin, and a key crisis comes up early on. My turn comes to add cards, and I put them on the table. My friend Aaron says something to the effect of "That's how a cylon plays cards." I pointed out that I couldn't possibly play cards that hurt us, since both of my colors were positive. He wasn't buying it though. Everyone seemed to ignore it after we passed the check. I was in fact a cylon in that game, and we did win when Admiral Tigh revealed himself as a bomber and destroyed Galactica. Aaron knows me pretty well, and he's perceptive, but for him to call it that early still makes me smile.
Monday, October 15, 2012
Hidden Gems: Gem Dealer Review

Gem Dealer
- Designed by Reiner Knizia
- Published by Gryphon Games in 2008
- For 3-5 Players
- Plays in 20-30 minutes
Overview
Gem Dealer is a race to collect 4 different types of gems. Players do so by bidding on one gem with cards in their hand. Knowing when to bid and when to bide your time is a crucial aspect of the game. It's fairly quick and keeps moving at a good pace.
Components
| Inside the box, rules are underneath |
The gems are very stunning, one of the prettiest game components I own. They don't look cheap, nor do they feel it. The cards are good quality, though differentiating between purple and blue in low/bad light is challenging at times.
Mechanics
There are 5 different gems, of which players are attempting to get 4. Players do so through a series of bidding rounds. The first player places a gem up for bid, and then plays cards matching that color. Each time they bid, they draw a card. Other players can up the bid, or pass, drawing one final card and waiting for the next round. There are some wild cards which can be used on any gem, though only one "10" can be used. The 10 comes at a risk though, if you're not successful in your bid, you must return a gem you already own. In each bid, a player may, one time, place any number of cards face down as a bid of 1 per card they play. This is a good way to get rid of cards of a color you already have. Overall, the mechanics are simple, but the wild cards and varying numbers on the gem cards do keep it interesting.
Interaction
![]() |
| All together now, "OOOOHHH SHINY!" |
A lot of Gem Dealer is figuring out who is going to bid on something, and what to put up for bid next. If everyone else has a blue gem, the odds are good that you'll be able to snag it without wasting too many cards. The interaction here is about what you'd find in any other auction, though players are limited by their cards, not their own stop sign.
Theme
The gems are a nice theme, but I'm playing an auction/bidding game. The theme could be animals, spaceship parts, etc. and the game would still work fine.
Learning Curve
Short. It can be taught in roughly 1-2 minutes. There are some of those weird exceptions, only one "10" and the facedown anything bid, but the game is still quick to get people in and playing.
| The different types of bid cards. See what I mean about Purple(right) and Blue(left)? |
Why I like Gem Dealer
It is a quick game with fun mechanics. I don't have many bidding games, and the other ones I have are longer games. The gems hook people instantly, and it opens the door to other games.
Why I don't like Gem Dealer
There's a bit too much luck with the bidding cards. Because players draw after each bid, one player could get a card of the color currently up for bid while another does not. Also, the more bids you can make, the more cards you have, meaning you'll likely have cards for the next gem as well.
Replayability
![]() |
| My sister is a gem hoarder |
I've played Gem Dealer 5 times in the last 2 or so years. I've played it mostly at long games days as something that doesn't require too much thinking. I think there's a time for it, but it's never at the top of anyone's want to play list. I think it can be played more often and still be fun.
Overall
I like the game, but it seems like everyone would rather play something else. Gem Dealer isn't a bad game, it just isn't great. Maybe that's due to the theme. If you look at tother games in the Gryphon Bookshelf line, theme plays a bigger part. I give it 1 thumb up.
Want to buy Gem Dealer and support BoBG?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





