Top Games

As of January 2015

1. Cosmic Encounter
2. Star Trek: Attack Wing
3. Resistance: Avalon
4. Ticket to Ride
5. Escape: Curse of the Temple
6. Dominion
7. Incan Gold
8. Suburbia
9. Splendor
10. Star Trek: Fleet Captains
11. 7 Wonders
12. For Sale
13. Kingsburg
14. Alhambra
15. Carcassonne 
16. X-Wing
17. King of Tokyo
18. Lost Cities
19. Diamonds
20. Pandemic
21. Dice Masters
22. Article 27 
23. Camel Up
24. Bohnanza
25. Small World
26. Battlestar Galactica
27. Machi Koro
28. Love Letter
29. Shadows Over Camelot
30. Hanabi
31. Marvel Legendary
32. Takenoko
33. Roll Through the Ages
34. Flash Point Fire Rescue
35. No Thanks
36. Star Realms 
37. Wits&Wagers
38. Formula D
39. Dixit
40. Qwixx
41. Rattus
42. 1960: The Making of the President
43. Settlers of Catan (Cities and Knights or Star Trek)
44. Smash Up
45. TransAmerica
46. Can't Stop
47. Survive: Escape from Atlantis
48. Tsuro
49. Bonkers
50. Power Grid

As of January 2014

1. Cosmic Encounter
2.  Star Trek: Attack Wing
3.  Resistance: Avalon
4.  Ticket to Ride
5.  King of Tokyo
6.  7 Wonders
7.  For Sale
8.  Incan Gold
9.  Star Wars: X-Wing
10. Article 27
11. Dominion
12. Star Trek: Fleet Captains
13. Battlestar Galactica
14. Shadows Over Camelot
15. Escape: Curse of the Temple
16. Love Letter
17. Alhambra
18. Hanabi
19. Marvel Legendary
20. Flash Point
21. Pandemic
22. Roll Through the Ages 
23. Dixit 
24. Small World 
25. Forbidden Desert 
26. Eight-Minute Empire 
27. Takenoko 
28. Fleet 
29. Kingsburg 
30. Can't Stop
31. Risk Legacy
32. Formula D
33. Catacombs
34. Wits and Wagers
35. Rattus
36. Seasons
37. Carcassonne
38. Tsuro 
39. Survive: Escape from Atlantis
40. No Thanks
41. Power Grid
42. Eminent Domain
43. 1960: The Making of the President
44. Settlers of Catan (Cities and Knights or Star Trek)
45. TransAmerica
46. Eclipse
47. Zooloretto/Aquaretto
48. Bonkers
49. Agricola
50. Qwixx

My list as of January 2013.

1. Cosmic Encounter
2. Ticket to Ride
3. 7 Wonders
4. Dominion
5. X-Wing
6. Battlestar Galactica
7. Star Trek: Fleet Captains
8. Shadows Over Camelot
9. Incan Gold
10. For Sale
11. Roll Through the Ages
12. Dixit
13. Pandemic
14. Rattus
15. Can't Stop
16. Fleet
17. Catacombs
18. Small World
19. This Game is Bonkers
20. Tsuro
21. Eminent Domain
22. Forbidden Island
23. No Thanks
24. Carcassonne
25. Settlers of Catan
26. Flash Point: Fire Rescue
27. 1960: The Making of the President
28. Wits and Wagers
29. Risk Legacy
30. Scary Tales
31. Ultimate Werewolf
32. Lost Cities
33. Space Hulk: Death Angel
34. Black Friday
35. Kingsburg
36. Power Grid
37. Tiki Topple
38. Seasons
39. Formula D
40. Colossal Arena
41. Say Anything
42. The Game of Life: Jedi's Path

The 2012 List

1. Cosmic Encounter
2. Dominion
3. Ticket to Ride
4. 7 Wonders
5. Battlestar Galactica
6. Eminent Domain
7. Star Trek: Fleet Captains
8. Shadows Over Camelot
9. Rattus
10. Incan Gold
11. Forbidden Island
12. Dixit
13. Pandemic
14. Catacombs
15. Roll Through the Ages
16. Settlers of Catan
17. Space Hulk: Death Angel
18. Small World
19. Carcassonne
20. 1960 Making of the President
21. Werewolf/Mafia
22. For Sale
23. Risk Legacy
24. Tiki Topple
25. Wits and Wagers
26. Race for the Galaxy
27. Kingsburg
28. This Game is Bonkers
29. High Society
30. Formula D
31. Power Grid
32. Mr. Jack
33. The Adventurers (Temple of Chac)
34. Fauna
35. Star Wars Life: A Jedi's Path
36. Colossal Arena
37. Give Me the Brain
38. Say Anything
39. Mystery Express
40. Blokus
41. No Thanks
42. Sorry Sliders